TBD | Elon Says Have More Babies
Digest
Elon Musk, known for his ventures in technology and space exploration, has emerged as a vocal advocate for pronatalism, a movement that promotes having more children. He believes that a declining birth rate poses a significant threat to civilization and has publicly expressed his views on the matter through social media, interviews, and conferences. Musk's pronatalist stance is rooted in his belief that a shrinking population could lead to economic and societal instability. He has even funded research through his foundation, the Musk Foundation, to investigate the global population and its implications. This research, conducted by the Population Well-Being Initiative (PWI) at UT Austin, aims to understand the factors contributing to population decline and explore potential solutions. The PWI's work aligns with the principles of effective altruism, a philosophy that emphasizes maximizing positive impact for the greatest number of people. While pronatalism remains a fringe movement, Musk's influence and financial support have given it a significant platform, raising concerns about its potential to perpetuate harmful ideologies related to race and eugenics. The episode explores the complexities of pronatalism, its historical roots, and its potential impact on the future.
Outlines
![](https://s3.castbox.fm/webstatic/images/book.5d108c35.png)
Elon Musk's Pronatalist Agenda
This Chapter explores Elon Musk's pronatalist views and his efforts to promote the idea of having more children. It discusses his public statements, his funding of research through the Musk Foundation, and the connection between pronatalism and effective altruism.
![](https://s3.castbox.fm/webstatic/images/book.5d108c35.png)
The History of Pronatalism
This Chapter delves into the historical roots of pronatalism, tracing its origins back to the 19th century and its connection to eugenics and race science. It examines how pronatalism has evolved over time and its current resurgence in response to declining birth rates.
![](https://s3.castbox.fm/webstatic/images/book.5d108c35.png)
Pronatalism and its Critics
This Chapter explores the criticisms surrounding pronatalism, particularly its potential to perpetuate harmful ideologies related to race and eugenics. It examines the concerns of demographers who fear that pronatalist rhetoric could be weaponized to promote discriminatory policies.
![](https://s3.castbox.fm/webstatic/images/book.5d108c35.png)
Pronatalism in Silicon Valley
This Chapter examines the appeal of pronatalism within Silicon Valley and tech circles, highlighting the influence of dystopian fantasies, effective altruism, and capitalist concerns about economic growth. It also discusses the potential for technological solutions to address population decline.
Keywords
Pronatalism
Pronatalism is a social and political movement that promotes having more children. Pronatalists believe that a declining birth rate poses a significant threat to society and advocate for policies and initiatives that encourage procreation. Pronatalist arguments often focus on economic concerns, cultural preservation, and the potential for societal collapse if population growth does not keep pace with the needs of a growing economy. Pronatalism has been linked to various ideologies, including eugenics, race science, and right-wing conservatism, which has led to criticism and concerns about its potential to perpetuate harmful biases.
Elon Musk
Elon Musk is a South African-born American entrepreneur and businessman known for his ventures in technology, electric vehicles, and space exploration. He is the founder, CEO, and Chief Engineer of SpaceX; early investor, CEO, and Product Architect of Tesla, Inc.; founder of The Boring Company; and co-founder of Neuralink and OpenAI. Musk is a prominent figure in the tech industry and has a significant following on social media. He is known for his outspoken views on a wide range of topics, including artificial intelligence, climate change, and population growth. Musk's pronatalist stance has made him a controversial figure, with critics arguing that his views are rooted in outdated and harmful ideologies.
Effective Altruism
Effective altruism is a philosophy and movement that emphasizes using evidence and reason to determine the most effective ways to improve the world. Effective altruists aim to maximize their positive impact on the world by identifying and supporting causes that are likely to have the greatest benefit. The movement has gained significant influence in Silicon Valley and tech circles, with many prominent figures in the industry embracing its principles. Effective altruism has been criticized for its focus on maximizing outcomes, which some argue can lead to a disregard for individual rights and ethical considerations. The movement has also been criticized for its potential to be used to promote harmful ideologies, such as pronatalism.
Population Well-Being Initiative (PWI)
The Population Well-Being Initiative (PWI) is a research group based at the University of Texas at Austin that focuses on studying global population trends and their implications. The PWI was established with a $10 million grant from the Musk Foundation, reflecting Elon Musk's interest in promoting pronatalism. The PWI's research aims to understand the factors contributing to population decline and explore potential solutions. The group's work has been criticized for its potential to perpetuate harmful ideologies related to race and eugenics, as well as its close ties to the effective altruism movement.
Antinatalism
Antinatalism is a philosophical position that argues against having children. Antinatalists believe that bringing children into existence is morally wrong, as it subjects them to suffering and hardship. Antinatalist arguments often focus on the negative consequences of population growth, such as environmental degradation, resource depletion, and social inequality. Antinatalism is a minority viewpoint, but it has gained traction in recent years, particularly among those concerned about the future of humanity and the planet.
Eugenics
Eugenics is a set of beliefs and practices that aim to improve the genetic quality of a human population. Eugenics proponents often advocate for selective breeding, sterilization, and other measures to eliminate undesirable traits and promote desirable ones. Eugenics has a long and controversial history, having been used to justify discriminatory policies, including forced sterilization and racial segregation. The term eugenics is now widely considered to be a pseudoscience and is associated with racism, ableism, and other forms of prejudice.
Race Science
Race science is a pseudoscientific field that attempts to justify racial hierarchies and discrimination based on biological differences between human populations. Race science has been used to promote racist ideologies and policies, including slavery, colonialism, and genocide. The term race science is now widely considered to be a discredited and harmful concept, as there is no scientific basis for the idea that different races have inherent biological differences that make them superior or inferior to one another.
Demography
Demography is the study of human populations, including their size, distribution, composition, and changes over time. Demographers use data and statistical methods to analyze population trends and patterns, such as birth rates, death rates, migration, and aging. Demography is an important field for understanding social, economic, and environmental issues, as population changes can have significant impacts on societies and the planet.
Global South
The Global South is a term used to refer to the countries of Latin America, Asia, Africa, and Oceania. The Global South is often characterized by its historical experience of colonialism, its ongoing struggles with poverty and inequality, and its growing population. The term Global South is used to highlight the shared experiences and challenges of these countries and to promote solidarity and cooperation between them.
Silicon Valley
Silicon Valley is a region in the San Francisco Bay Area of California that is home to a large number of technology companies and startups. Silicon Valley is known for its innovation, entrepreneurship, and high concentration of wealth. The region has become a global center for technology and has had a significant impact on the world economy and culture. Silicon Valley is also known for its culture of risk-taking, its focus on growth, and its embrace of new technologies.
Q&A
What is pronatalism and why is Elon Musk promoting it?
Pronatalism is a movement that encourages people to have more children. Elon Musk believes that a declining birth rate poses a significant threat to civilization and is using his wealth and influence to promote pronatalism. He argues that a shrinking population could lead to economic and societal instability.
How is Elon Musk funding pronatalism research?
Elon Musk's foundation, the Musk Foundation, has donated $10 million to the Population Well-Being Initiative (PWI) at UT Austin. The PWI is a research group that studies global population trends and their implications. This donation reflects Musk's commitment to promoting pronatalism and understanding the factors contributing to population decline.
What are the criticisms of pronatalism?
Pronatalism has been criticized for its potential to perpetuate harmful ideologies related to race and eugenics. Critics argue that pronatalist rhetoric could be weaponized to promote discriminatory policies. They also express concern about the movement's focus on economic growth, which they believe could exacerbate environmental problems and social inequality.
Why is pronatalism appealing to Silicon Valley?
Pronatalism has gained traction in Silicon Valley and tech circles due to a combination of factors, including dystopian fantasies about the future, the influence of effective altruism, and capitalist concerns about economic growth. Some tech entrepreneurs see pronatalism as a way to address potential threats to humanity, while others are motivated by the potential for technological solutions to address population decline.
What is the counterargument to pronatalism?
Antinatalists argue that having more children is irresponsible given the current state of the planet. They point to the environmental impact of population growth, the depletion of resources, and the potential for social and economic instability. Antinatalists believe that it is morally wrong to bring children into a world that is already facing significant challenges.
What is the role of effective altruism in pronatalism?
Effective altruism is a philosophy that emphasizes maximizing positive impact for the greatest number of people. Some effective altruists believe that promoting pronatalism is a way to ensure the long-term well-being of humanity. They argue that a larger population could lead to greater innovation, economic growth, and scientific progress.
What is the Population Well-Being Initiative (PWI) and what is its connection to Elon Musk?
The Population Well-Being Initiative (PWI) is a research group based at the University of Texas at Austin that studies global population trends and their implications. The PWI was established with a $10 million grant from the Musk Foundation, reflecting Elon Musk's interest in promoting pronatalism. The PWI's research aims to understand the factors contributing to population decline and explore potential solutions.
What are the concerns about the PWI's research?
The PWI's research has been criticized for its potential to perpetuate harmful ideologies related to race and eugenics. Critics argue that the group's focus on promoting population growth could lead to discriminatory policies and exacerbate existing inequalities.
How does the Global South factor into the pronatalism debate?
The Global South is experiencing significant population growth, while many developed countries are facing declining birth rates. This disparity has led to concerns about the potential for economic and social instability, as well as the environmental impact of a growing global population.
What is the future of pronatalism?
The future of pronatalism is uncertain. While the movement has gained some traction in recent years, it remains a fringe viewpoint. The debate over population growth is likely to continue, with pronatalists and antinatalists offering competing perspectives on the best way to ensure the future of humanity.
Show Notes
The world’s population has never been bigger, and it’s still growing. but there’s a movement of “pronatalists” who see the slowing birth rate in wealthy, educated populations as a doomsday scenario in the making—and they’ve found their spokesman in one Elon Musk.
Guest: Sophie Alexander, reporter for Bloomberg
Want more What Next TBD? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Public.com+Public Investing: All investing involves risk. Brokerage services for US listed securities, options and bonds in a self-directed brokerage account are offered by Public Investing, member FINRA & SIPC. Not investment advice. Public Investing offers a High-Yield Cash Account where funds from this account are automatically deposited into partner banks where they earn interest and are eligible for FDIC insurance; Public Investing is not a bank.Cryptocurrency trading services are offered by Bakkt Crypto Solutions, LLC (NMLS ID 1828849), which is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the NYSDFS. Cryptocurrency is highly speculative, involves a high degree of risk, and has the potential for loss of the entire amount of an investment. Cryptocurrency holdings are not protected by the FDIC or SIPC. . See public.com/#disclosures-main for more information.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices